Hollyoaks ‘train death’ unsuitable says Ofcom

Hollyoaks Train Fight

Channel 4 has been ticked off by television regulator Ofcom over ‘graphic’ scenes shown in teen-aimed soap opera Hollyoaks in which a character was killed by a train.

Ofcom noted the scenes, broadcast on E4 at 7pm and Channel 4 at 6.30pm in March this year were too violent and shocking for a early evening audience. The dramatic showdown between the characters of Simon Walker and Brendan Brady resulted in the gruesome death of Walker when his rival pushed him into the oncoming train. The plot had been part of an ongoing storyline which had played out across a year.

In the series Brady was a notorious bad guy and drug dealer. Channel 4 defended the scenes noting they felt the sequences complied with the broadcasting codes for UK television. Ofcom however disagreed.

There was an expectation from viewers that there would be a dramatic end to such a complex tense relationship. – Channel 4

The broadcaster noted that the violence was ‘signposted’ via the script in the episode and Lime Pictures who produce the programme for the channel had shown great caution in how much graphic footage was included by editing the number of punches and monitoring the ‘nasty’ sounds.

The sequence, while lasting less than two minutes at the end of the episode however was deemed too violent to be screened before 9pm. The regulator noted that ten percent of Hollyoaks’ audience, while aimed at teens, is actually made up of young children aged between four and nine years old. The regulator therefore suggested this edition of Hollyoaks had the “potential to distress younger viewers as well as raise concerns about the level of violence amongst parents watching with their children”

It isn’t the first time the regulator has come down on teatime soap operas, during the 1960s and 70s ITV’s most successful daytime soap opera – Crossroads – was frequently being told to tone down storylines in order to not scare younger viewers.

In 1969 a witchcraft storyline had to be wrapped up early after Ofcom – then known as the ITA – declared the scenes too graphic for a 6.30pm audience. A later 1973 storyline involving a suicide, co-incidentally involving a train, had to show none of the impact or death.

In the past the television regulator has allowed Channel 4 more freedom than it would with ‘mainstream’ channels such as BBC One and ITV. Brookside was allowed to be more visually disturbing than its fellow ITV soaps while in 1982 the regulator banned a television series, At Last It’s Mike Elliott by Tyne Tees Television, from airing on ITV, however deemed it acceptable for a Channel 4 audience.

The ITA, later IBA, also had a dubious quality list which noted programming which was, in their view, too low brow. Coronation Street and Crossroads were both on this list despite both pulling in millions of viewers a week.

[EasyGallery id=’hollyoakstrain’]