Think Tank Want Changes at the BBC and Channel 4

Image: BBC North. ATV Network PhotographA policy exchange group has suggested the BBC needs a major overhaul to cut the millions it spends chasing young people, sport viewers and entertainment programming. The Policy Exchange members also believe Channel 4 should be privatised, however it should – they said – keep its public service remit until at least 2022.

 

 

BBC Three also doesn’t sit well with the panel – they believe the money would be better spent over on E4 or Channel 4’s T4 strand. Of course shows such as EastEnders prove popular with a younger audience, which is why over the years it has been dumbed down to appeal to the lowest IQ level viewer – and this is on mainstream BBC One.

 

SoapChat’s executive, Pamela, comments on the BBC teen-reaching formular of EastEnders: “Ian sleeps with Janine, he is blackmailed, and he becomes a suspect [in Archie’s murder]. His wife will find out… [their relationship] is over and she is back with him before the week is out. Because that plotline has nothing to do with the characters, it’s totally led to add another suspect to the list.

“On another level everyone else, aside from Max, Stacey, her mum and probably Tania is written as a cliché. That’s why I find it difficult to care about the characters. Combine that with the story led format, it all becomes rather two dimensional. It’s now about over the top drama. That’s now the format, fast and furious… and comes across as badly written/produced. But the teens love it, its like McDonalds.”

 

 

But whether the proposed changes would see the BBC add quality back into some of its primetime long running productions remains to be seen.

BBC Logo, Image: ATV Network“It appears a lot of it is about youth and ratings these days over quality and substance.” adds ATV soap critic Justin Mason. “Gone are the days when a well crafted script was deemed top priority. Although this isn’t exclusive to the BBC, it is true that EastEnders has scripts often below the standard of Hollyoaks. If you close your eyes you can hear scripts being read, it isn’t speech at all. The viewers, young viewers, are not seemingly interested in good storytelling, good plots. They said the single episode with Dot was boring. Yet it was beautifully written. They want gimmicks, they want sensational. They vote for pretty pictures and dramatic scenes, what is being said isn’t important. The BBC should be fighting against this trend, not trailblazing it with their primetime soap.”

 

Under question also are the fees paid to “top talent” – and the word talent used loosely with some of the names. For example the reported £6m a year salary of Jonathan Ross:

 

 

“The problem was not so much what the BBC paid, but what the BBC was doing in the bidding ring in the first place,” the report notes.

 

 

The BBC, self-indulgent and self-important to some, has been questioned in the past on the amount of television tax it spends each year.

 

 

It isn’t unheard of for the BBC to waste licence fee money on poorly thought out ideas. The BBC North West studios were refitted, only to be closed down and never used. BBC Midlands relocated to a building which the BBC doesn’t own – yet the BBC paid for its entire refurbishment. The rent costing more in the long-term than it would have cost to upgrade the former iconic, and fondly remembered, Pebble Mill studios. And those are just two incidents in a long list..

 

 

The report goes on to suggest the BBC Trust should be scrapped and commercial arm BBC Worldwide sold off and privatised.

 

The BBC have responded by saying that “any proposed change must not put the public value of the BBC or its independence against inappropriate political or commercial influence at risk.”

 

The report also suggests the Labour government should not try to impose a broadband tax.