BBC Hospital Drama’s Blasted

The BBC’s two hospital based dramas, Casualty and spin-off series Holby City, have been blasted by a top NHS manager for their unrealistic and unprofessional representation of NHS workers.

BBCCasualty and spin-off series Holby City are once again coming under fire for their unrealistic and unprofessional portrayal of NHS workers, or so argues one top NHS manager. The two medical dramas have been the subject of similar criticisms before from voices within the NHS. This time the criticism comes from Antony Sumara who is the manager for the Mid-Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust. Mr Sumara took over the trust after a damning report earlier this year which exposed “appalling” failings in care.

BBCMr Sumara’s attack on Casualty and Holby City was made in the “Scrubbing Up” column on the BBC website. His article argues that the job of NHS workers is being made harder because the public’s perception of them and the NHS in general is being shaped by dramas such as Holby and Casualty. Amongst his criticisms of the show are the way the nurses refer to patients, such as ‘alkies’, staff who gossip in front of patients, routine breaches of data protection laws and other unprofessional behaviour routinely displayed in both dramas. 

BBCBoth dramas continue to be popular with BBC audiences and routinely attract over five million viewers. Casualty has been on air since 1986 and is the longest running medical drama in the world. Spin-off series Holby City was launched in 1999 and now airs all year round. A short-lived police spin-off, Holby Blue, was launched in 2007 but after two seasons was cancelled due to low ratings. Criticisms aimed at Holby and Casualty are nothing new to either drama with previous criticisms focusing on excessive use of alcohol by nurses in Holby City.