Benefits Row Live: Round-up

Some have called for the revival of Tyne Tees TV’s Friday Live! or Central Television’s Central Weekend as Benefits Row Live on Channel 5 last night reminded viewers that a late night barney is great television viewing.

You’ve watched the shows on every channel, you’ve read the headlines in every paper” – Matthew Wright introduced The Big Benefits Row: Live at 9pm last night on Channel 5; a live debate show where tempers flared on a topic which has gripped the nation.

Panellists and audience members were invited with ardent views and experience on the topic, and included Benefits Street’s ‘White Dee’, journalist Katie Hopkins, ex-MP Edwina Currie, politician Ken Livingstone, ex-benefits claimant Annabel Giles, Reverend Steve Chalke, journalist Sam Delaney, broadcaster Terry Christian, writer and poverty campaigner Jack Monroe, journalist Rachel Johnson, editor of The Spectator Fraser Nelson, Independent journalist Owen Jones, reality star of ‘The Fairy Jobmother’ Hayley Taylor and many more with often aggressive and explosive views on benefits and how the system has failed us.

Benefits Street’s Deirdre Kelly, aka ‘White Dee’, made a composed first live TV appearance and declared, “I’d prefer to be working.” She said the show was four families on the street out of 100 houses. “What you don’t see is other people doing exactly the same as me… I’m the only person being shown on the documentary.”

She said she found the show, “surreal. I didn’t think anybody would actually watch it, [but that the] …majority of it has been lovely… loads of really nice messages.”

“I haven’t been on benefits my whole life”, she said, speaking about her situation. “It’s just at the moment…. I suffer from depression; I’m being assessed for bipolar disorder. I have a good day, I have 3 bad days, then I have like 2 good days. What employer would, you know, [employ me] if I said I can’t come in for three days?”

Katie Hopkins countered Dee’s claims, despite Matthew Wright interceding “she’s sick, she’s just told you she’s sick”, maintaining that viewers have seen her swearing around her children on screen, and surely she’s the “patron saint of drug users, drop outs and drug users. In the last round of the disability allowance 1 million people were found fit to work.”

Sam Delaney argued, “the amount of people fraudulently claiming benefits is negligible, less than 4%,” and argued that the media were to blame for the misconception of benefits claimants. “The way to spin a programme around audiences [is with] issues that are simple, polarising and have drama. [It’s] to sell papers, to attract audiences. A problem with the show [Benefits Street] is I watched expecting to be offended [but it’s a] compassionate and fair reflection. If we sympathise with people out of work it doesn’t mean we don’t like people in work.”

Terry Christian similarly felt the media could be to blame. “The media is 70% privately educated. [It could be a] much more interesting documentary if you turned that camera around 180 degrees.”

Annabel Giles was vocal about the difficulties she had going from owning a luxurious house in Mustique to living on benefits: “No one wants to be treated like scum. My son’s father left when he [the son] was two weeks old…benefits would be cut in half if we went after the absent parent a bit harder. You’re paying the carer more than you pay yourself.”

Katie Hopkins was less forgiving of mothers struggling to make ends meet, and took on Annabel’s story personally. “I was left with my babies when I was two weeks old. What we’re going to keep hearing time and time again is excuses. All I hear is someone who wanted to be a model but didn’t make it. Why do people on benefits think they can have as many children as they like?” Annabel Giles hit back: “You would be really dangerous if you knew what you were talking about.”

Ken Livingstone interceded to point out that only 2000 families in the UK have over eight children, with most with less than two. His view of the problem was the UK’s changing working model: “The job’s working class men have done have been wiped out.”

Reverend Steve Chalke talked particularly on the issues which Channel 4’s Benefits Street has thrown at the school he has taken on; Oasis Foundry Academy school on James Turner Street. “We took on the school to turn it around. Every single day there are tourists riding up and down the street… tourists had taken their trousers down outside the school gate to have their photograph taken. If children are scared to walk down the street, if they’re not coming to school, if they’re frightened they’re not learning – that is the impact of this programme on the school.”

Peter Stringfellow in the audience suggested, “the problem with benefits is a few, not the majority of people. Abuse of the system is what this program is about.”

Matthew Wright pointed out, “we’ve had no tax cuts for the super-rich but cut after cut on welfare,” when Edwina Currie sharply divided the audience. “One of the problems we’ve got,” she ventured, “is that pensioner numbers are rising all the time.”

“What about tax avoidance?” asked Matthew. Edwina countered, “You’ve got to tackle both; they’re not alternatives.”

Journalist Rachel Johnson (and sister of Boris Johnson) had investigated life on that side of the fence. “I spent a week living on a pound a day… what I found was not that people were scrounging but people were finding it hard to get their benefits because 10% of jobseekers are having their benefits sanctioned… this is not going to put Ocado out of business.”

When Currie sharply defended food banks, Twitter adversary, writer and poverty campaigner Jack Monroe argued that they weren’t an easy ride. “You can’t just roll up with a carrier bag and help yourself….. We’re not the f*cking Johnsons. We’re not loaded, we’re not middle class. I failed my grammar school.”

“I bet the bookmakers have lost a fortune,” ‘White Dee’ said wryly. “I bet they thought I’d be the first to swear.”

Sophie Green from Channel 5’s On Benefits & Proud had outspoken views. “That programme has made me something I’m not. I’m a single mother on my own. I volunteer at charity ships to try and get my degree for my child. You know nothing about my life,” she yelled. “Give me job innit! My CV is everywhere!” as a chant of ‘every mother is a working mother’ built in the audience.

Edwina Currie spoke about how immigrants appear to be more prepared to do any job in the UK. “We are importing people from all over the world to do the job she won’t do.” Reality star The Fairy Jobmother Hayley Taylor also referred to “job snobbery” in the UK.

Fraser Nelson from The Spectator said that Britain owed a “debt” to immigrants. “They come here to work, 1000 immigrants a day. The system takes money off you [the British] as fast as you earn it… Who would work under that system?”

Owen Jones said immigration was, “a 2 way process… we are the 10th biggest source of immigrants on the face of the earth.”

Matthew asked Dee if she would ever be off benefits. “Definitely,” she asserted. “I hope its sooner rather than later, but it’s all personal circumstances… every individual is different, their circumstances are different and that’s why you can’t tar everybody with the same brush.”

Other participants involved were: Sophie Green from On Benefits & Proud, Julia Hartley-Brewer, Shaun Bailey, Robert Oxley (Taxpayers’ Alliance), Alexandra Swann (UKIP), Ava Vidal, Susie Boniface, Paris Lees, Sarfraz Manzoor, Stephanie Navarro, Sophie Anderton, Matthew Reed (Children’s Society), Sue Marsh (Diary of a Benefits Scrounger), Simon Danczuk MP, Dr Evan Harris MP and Margot James MP.

Well seen as Channel 5 is reviving ITV’s old Police 5 series, why not dig into their format archive once more and bring back the madness that was Friday Live! ? Clip of the opening titles below: