Producers of a new Channel 4 documentary series are in the firing line of its own ‘stars’ as residents of West Midlands’ Winson Green hit back at the ‘misleading’ programme.
It isn’t the first time Channel 4 has broadcast pro-Tory propaganda attempting to endorse their view that all unemployed people are scroungers, however this time the estate concerned has hit-back at the producers.
The Birmingham Mail reports that ‘documentary makers betrayed Birmingham community’s trust’ and instead of showing a balanced impartial view of life for people struggling to survive the documentary has made them seem like Britain’s worst state spongers.
The five-part series was sold to the residents, they say, as a documentary strand which would show the neighbourly togetherness of a low-income community with the focus on James Turner Street.
However they say the inflammatory titled Benefits Street actually tries to make the residents out to be anti-social benefit scroungers.
Which will be music to David Cameron’s ears. There has yet to be a documentary by Channel 4 which shows the many deaths due to the cut-backs, the many disabled struggling to cope or those like Maria Brabiner who had worked all her life and is now stuck on benefits due to no fault of her own. I don’t believe there has been a probing documentary into the real scroungers – yes MPs – or how many low paid workers are worse off thanks to the Tories? No I didn’t think so. – ATV critic Queenie
Now the Birmingham Mail reports that several of the show’s subjects, who have watched the first three editions and the Channel 4 trailers at a special screening, suggest they have been betrayed by Channel 4 and production company Love Productions. Serious allegations from some featured in the programme also claim private conversations were recorded without consent.
One of those featured is 32-year-old Dee Roberts who told the Midland newspaper that she had been edited to only bring to the screen negatives, all the positiveness had been wiped from the series.
They said they wanted to film for a TV show about how great community spirit is in the street and how we all help each other out on a daily basis.‘They said that ‘Britain was broken’ but that I lived in an area where the community was very close. I participated in the show on that belief.
But this programme has nothing to do with community, which you can tell from the title. It’s all about people in the street living off benefits, taking drugs and dossing around all day. It makes people out as complete scum. They have edited everything to suit their own needs, taken a positive and turned it into a negative. – Dee Roberts in the Birmingham Mail
Channel 4 say of the programme that it aims to reveal the reality of life on benefits, as the residents of one of Britain’s most benefit-dependent streets invite cameras into their tight-knit community. According to some politicians and media coverage, benefits are an easy route to a life of luxury, foreign holidays and lavish homes furnished with wide screen TVs – all at the expense of hard-working taxpayers. The series follows residents of ‘Benefits Street’ as they navigate their way through life on the bottom rung of Britain’s economic ladder.
These shows are made by middle class luvvies darling who wouldn’t have a clue how to survive on £70 a week. They pay that much for their celebratory champers over lunch. – ATV Critic Queenie
